Like many of you, I received the iPhone 3GS on June 19th. I upgraded from the original iPhone, and I’m here to tell you about my thoughts and observations between the two devices.
Speed: The 3GS’ namesake is speed- and for good reason. There is no more lag. At all. Everything opens fast- especially the camera which always gave me problems with the 2G iPhone.
Win for the 3GS
3G- 3G is easily four times as fast as EDGE. However, there are problems with 3G that I will enumerate on in the next section.
3GS-2 2G-0
Reception- This is probably more related to AT&T than the iPhone itself. When the 3GS has signal, it is great. Crystal clear, nice and loud calls. Much louder than the 2G! However, my experience with signal is awful. If you are out in the open, there are few problems. But anything seems to be a source of interference that degrades the signal to complete lack of usability. I will probably take the phone into the nearest Apple Store to get it checked out and see if it is a problem with my phone. The 2G never had great signal, but it was consistently a decent signal. I have used the phone in a slightly rural area, a medium city, and a large city (Whoa, I have done some serious traveling this past week).
Winner- 2G iPhone
Design- I never liked the look of the newer iPhones, but having used it, I really like how it feels in your hand. The oleophobic screen is a work of art- probably will still put a screen protector on it just in case though. The plastic back attracts grease and fingerprints like none other, but I have a Griffin Clarifi case that I can pick up Monday (Look for a review soon).
Winner- 3GS (Score is 3-1)
Hardware- The 3.0mp camera with autofocus is great. I used to not be able to take a close-up picture with the 2G camera (which influenced the purchase of the Clarifi) but the new camera seems to work very well with most shots. The compass, by itself, is nearly useless unless you are hiking. The Compass integrated with Google Maps is great. Makes it easy to navigate a new city! The video camera works very well- my only complaint is that I forget to switch from still to video cameras. Great quality in all of these aspects. Well, except for Voice Control. It is awful. I have yet to get the phone to do ANYTHING that I wanted it to by using VC. It got to the point where I decided to be juvenile and start commanding the phone using words that are inappropriate for this particular site
. When I did this, one of my family members was called. Maybe VC knows something I don’t?
Considering the 2G had none of these features without jailbreaking, it is obviously another win for the 3GS. (4-1 3GS)
Battery life- After a week, I was kind of hoping that the battery life of the 3GS would begin to get better. So far, it sucks; the phone eats up battery at a huge rate compared to the 2G iPhone due to its increased power. However, I am using the phone a lot because I love 3G when I have it. I can only hope that battery life improves. I will wait to pass final judgement on the 3GS until later, but until then, the 2G wins hands down.

So, the 3G S wins handily over its older sibling. Even though it might not have been a fair fight, I’ve enjoyed every second of it. We now return to your regulary scheduled programming.